|
|||||||||||||||||||||
Introduction
| At a Glance | |
|---|---|
| Product | - Belkin N1 Vision Wireless Router (F5D8232-4) - Belkin N1 Wireless Notebook Card (F5D8011C) |
| Summary | Wi-Fi Certified 802.11n Draft 2.0 router and CardBus card based on Atheros XSPAN silicon. |
| Pros | • Gigabit switch supports Jumbo Frames • Surprisingly bandwidth friendly to neighboring legacy WLANs |
| Cons | • 2.4 GHz band only • Very basic routing feature set |
Belkin created a bit of a stir when it introduced the N1 Vision Wireless Router back in July. Its vertical orientation and graphic front panel status display gave it an elegant look and style that set it apart from the ho-hum crowd. Now that the router and its Notebook Card have received Wi-Fi 802.11n Draft 2.0 certification, it's time to see if it has the performance to match its looks.
The Vision is designed to sit upright only—it has no wall-mounting slots and can't be laid flat on a desktop. The usual array of front panel status lights (Figure 1) has been replaced with a graphic display that Belkin touts as "The most advanced interactive network display".
Figure 1: N1 Vision Front Panel
I didn't find the display to be that useful, however, maybe because I was turned off by the heavy pressure required by the navigation button cluster. I had to hold the router with one hand and tilt it up to see the display properly while I pressed hard to get my button-presses to register.
Granted, there are a couple of handy features accessible via the display and front-panel keypad that you otherwise would have to launch a web browser to access. You can initiate the router end of a Wi-Fi Protected Setup (WPS) session, enable / disable the radio, and enable Guest Access.
The last feature provides a second SSID, with its own security key to wireless clients whose traffic is kept separated from that on the main SSID. This feature is only available, however, when either WPA or WPA2 security is enabled.
I was also disappointed that the "Broadband Speedometers" didn't provide a peak-hold type of indication as implied in the user manual. You get only a graphic and numerical readout of current average speed. There also weren't speedometers for wireless traffic, or even switched LAN traffic, which also would have been useful.
If you're intrigued by the front-panel feature, you should check out the summary of screens in the slideshow, or view Belkin's brief Flash demo.
The rear panel layout (Figure 2) is notable by what's not there, specifically link/activity indicators on each of the auto MDI / MDI-X 10/100/1000 Ethernet ports. So there is no way to quickly tell if you have a valid link. Instead you have to navigate to the front panel Connections / Speed page and run a ping or file transfer to see if the bits are flowing.
Figure 2: N1 Vision Rear Panel
User reviews
Average user rating from: 1 user(s)
good while it lasts
I bought this because I thought the screen was cool, I'm a sucker... After having it for an hour I realized it wasn't all that helpful, especially when I offload DHCP to a server vs. running it on the router, every host showed up as unknown. But that's not a problem with Belkin, it's a problem with all routers since the hostname is not stored in the DHCP database as that service is shut off, and shouldn't be a gripe on my part.
Anyway, hoping DD-WRT might do something cool with the screen I anxiously went there, but interest seemed to have fallen off and never went anywhere. Belkin does make their code available open source so if I was smart enough I could have done something with that.
On to the problems, after getting it I saw people were having trouble with IPSec. Luckily I was able to find a firmware on the Belkin UK site which solved that, strangely that firmware never appeared on the US site until a year later.
Things worked beyond great for a year, when one day it started the reboot of death. Reboot, get partially done, reboot again, repeat. Not knowing it had a lifetime warranty I bought the Buffalo WZR-HP-G300NH, then noticed it had the lifetime warranty. So I sent it back in....
When it came back to me I was surprised it was a brand new one, but I had already fallen in love with the Buffalo for it's speed and reliability, so I gave this brand new router to my brother instead. A month later he calls me and says, "hey, this thing you gave me is just rebooting over and over again, did you ever see that?" Lifetime warranty is great, but not if you're switching it out monthly.
Related Items:
Slideshow: Belkin N1 Vision Wireless RouterSlideshow: Belkin N Wireless Router
Linksys WRT350N Wireless-N Gigabit Router with Storage Link Review
Slideshow: D-Link DIR-628 RangeBooster N Dual Band Router
Belkin N+ Wireless Router Reviewed
