Lost Password? No account yet? Sign up! Why bother?
  • Narrow screen resolution
  • Wide screen resolution
  • Auto width resolution
  • Increase font size
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size

SmallNetBuilder - Small Network Help

  
Home arrow Wireless arrow Wireless Reviews arrow Does HomePlug AV + 802.11g equal Wi-Fi Nirvana?
Does HomePlug AV + 802.11g equal Wi-Fi Nirvana? Print E-mail
Tim Higgins   
February 25, 2008

Features

I'm not going to go into a lot of detail on the 318S' routing features. I put enough screen shots of the admin screens in the slideshow so that you can get a good feel for it.

Suffice it to say that it has the features that you've come to expect in a basic consumer wireless router, plus a few extras. One of the extras is the ability to have up to three different LAN subnets.

There is also an "Any IP" feature that lets clients access the Internet, no matter what their IP settings are. This is handy if your company notebook is set up with static IP information. "Any IP" will let the notebook access the Internet when it's connected to the 318S, without having to futz with the network settings. (Note that "Any IP" only provides Internet access. It won't provide LAN connection.)

The 318S also has a Automatic Bandwidth Management feature, similar to that found in many D-Link routers. But instead of being based on Ubicom's StreamEngine technology, it uses Atheros' implementation.

Wireless features include a full selection of wireless security options including both Home (PSK) and Enterprise (RADIUS) versions of WPA and WPA2. Wi-Fi Protected Setup (WPS) is also available, but you need to make sure the router has V3.60(AMR.2) firmware or higher.

Check out the slideshow See the slideshow for an admin interface tour

Routing Performance

Unfortunately, the routing portion of the 318S is its weakest feature. Figure 4 shows a composite plot of WAN > LAN, LAN > WAN and simultaneous up and downlink routing throughput.

Routing performance
Click to enlarge image

Figure 4: Routing performance
NOTE!NOTE!
- Firmware used was V3.60(AMR.2) | 11/08/2007
- Testing was done using this procedure.

Throughput is a decent 55 Mbps when running in each direction by itself. But when the simultaneous up / down test showed reduced average performance, due to the large (and long) throughput dropouts that you can see in the plot.

Even worse, however, was the result of the Maximum Simultaneous Connection test. The 318S was able to handle only 16 simultaneous connections (8 up and 8 down). So this router is definitely not one for gamers, big P2P / Torrent users or busy LANs with multiple users.



Tags: HomePlug, powerline, WiFi, ZyXEL,

Related Articles:

Slideshow: Zyxel NBG318S Wireless Powerline Router
Cisco updates Linksys Powerline adapter lineup
Updated: Intellon Announces 2nd-gen HomePlug AV Chip
Slideshow: Netgear WNDR3300 RangeMax Dual-Band Wireless N Router
SMC to ship HomePlug AV adapter
 

Most Read

 
 

Over At The Forums

New firmware 2.1.0
see also http://forum.qnap.com/viewtopic.php?f=142&t=10052 i had already the beta's running with also iscsi. Many more features are there.

Your thoughts about QNAP TS-109 II
I'm at the point where DVD backups for my photos,mp3 is taken too much of my time. I'm thinking of using the TS-109 II to...

OpenWRT not working as wireless repeater bridge on Netgear WGR614L
Hi , I have flashed my wgr614l with openwrt firmware . I have tested it for wireless client bridge mode and it is working fine but I...

OpenWRT working as wireless client bridge on Netgear WGR614L
Hi everybody , I have flashed my Netgear WGR614L with openwrt firmware and have tested it for client bridge mode . It is working grt .......

DIY or buy used?
Hi everybody, I am looking for a new NAS solution for my office. 1. SITUATION I use with video files and animations a lot. The big video...

Slideshows

NETGEAR ReadyNAS Pro Western Digital ShareSpace QNAP TS-509 Pro D-Link DNS-343 4-Bay Network Storage Enclosure Thecus N3200 RAID 5 NAS D-Link DIR-628 RangeBooster N Dual Band Router More

Win This!

Enter to Win!

You could win a Trendnet TEW-633GR Wireless N Gigabit Router and two TEW-621PC 300Mbps Wireless N-Draft PC Cards

Learn How!

 

Ldr:0.00171089172363, Rct:0.00572896003723, Sky:0.00744009017944, Tlink:0.326081991196, TopPG:0.32618689537, GQV:0.326387882233 seconds to load.