SmallNetBuilder

Follow SmallNetBuilder
Follow SmallNetBuilder on TwitterConnect On Facebook Google+Get the SmallNetBuilder RSS Feed
You are here: LAN & WAN LAN & WAN Reviews NETGEAR XAVB5001 Powerline AV 500 Adapter Kit Reviewed - Performance-more, Closing Thoughts

NETGEAR XAVB5001 Powerline AV 500 Adapter Kit Reviewed - Performance-more, Closing Thoughts

Print E-mail
<< Prev - Page 3 of 3 - Next

Performance - more

Transmit (upload) tests showed a similar pattern, but with slightly higher throughput. Peak average throughput of 100 Mbps was obtained witih the adapters in different outlets. But once again, Figure 9 shows significant throughput variation in both Location A tests. Lowest throughput of 66 Mbps was obtained in the most distant test Location E.

NETGEAR XAV5001 throughput, three locations, transmit

Figure 9: NETGEAR XAV5001 throughput, three locations, transmit

The comparison in Table 2 once again shows significantly lower throughput loss as distance increases between adapters.

Product
(click link for throughput plot)
Test Locations
A C E
NETGEAR XAV5001 100.0 78.7 65.6
TRENDnet TPL-401E 70.1 46.7 26.3
Table 2: Transmit throughput summary

Figure 10 shows the TRENDnet transmit plots for your comparison pleasure.

TRENDnet TPL-401E throughput, three locations, transmit

Figure 10: TRENDnet TPL-401E throughput, three locations, transmit

I ran simultaneous up and download tests in each location to see if throughput could be increased witih more traffic streams. Figure 11 shows the just shy of 122 Mbps of total average throughput with the adapters in different outlets in Location A and simultaneous up and download tests running.

NETGEAR XAV5001 throughput, Location A, different outlets, simultaneous up and down

Figure 11: NETGEAR XAV5001 throughput, Location A, different outlets, simultaneous up and down

You can also check out simultaneous up / down plots for Location C and Location E.

Running four simultaneous streams, however, didn't provide higher total throughput as Figure 12 shows.

NETGEAR XAV5001 throughput, Location A, different outlets, four download streams

Figure 12: NETGEAR XAV5001 throughput, Location A, different outlets, four download streams

I didn't run noise immunity or interoperability tests, having already sufficiently explored those topics in the TRENDnet review.

The last test I ran (because I knew I'd be asked) was to view the Megamind 3 trailer that I used just the other day in Three Stream N For HD Streaming: Close, But No Cigar, i.e. my test of three-stream N for 1080p HD streaming.

I chose the farthest location E, which I measured having 68 Mbps of nice steady download throughput. I just opened the file stored on a Synology DS109+ using Quicktime 7.6.5. and looked for playback problems. I'm happy to report that while I still saw a bit of frame drop during the fastest action sequences, the clip otherwise played fine. I decided to also try VLC 1.1.7, which did not show any signs of playback problems.

Closing Thoughts

So it looks like design (or maybe just firmware level) does matter when it comes to "500 Mbps" HomePlug AV powerline adapters. And for now, NETGEAR's XAVB5001 kit is the one to buy if you want the best example of what this technology can do.

While you won't get 100 Mbps of throughput throughout your home, you can probably count on at least 60 Mbps of steady, dropout-free bandwidth. And when it comes to 1080p HD streaming, slower, but steadier wins the race.




Related Items:

NETGEAR XAVB5101 Powerline Nano 500 Set Reviewed
HomePlug AV 500 Adapter Roundup
Actiontec PWR500 and TRENDnet TPL-406E2K Powerline Adapters Reviewed
500 Mbps Not! : TRENDnet TPL-401E2K 500 Mbps Powerline AV Adapter Kit
How We Test Powerline Products

User reviews

Average user rating from: 4 user(s)

NOTE! Please post product reviews from actual experience only.
Questions, review comments and opinions about products not based on actual use will not be published.

User Rating    [Back to Top]
Overall: 
 
4.8 Features :
 
5.0 Performance :
 
5.0 Reliability :
 
4.5
 
Ratings (the higher the better)
Features*
 
Performance*
 
Reliability*
 
Comments*
    Please enter the security code.
 
 

latency issues

Overall rating: 
 
4.3
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
5.0
Reliability:
 
3.0
Reviewed by mark
April 13, 2011
Report this review
 

Also own a 200mbps Linksys Adapter which runs at 7.8MB/s with latency of 3.5ms.

Netgear dapter runs at 14.5MB/s, best latency is 2ms, but not conistent like Linksys, it jumps by as much as 100ms and remains that way for a while.

Until this is fixed my older Linksys PLK300 is much better for gaming and VOIP.

Netgear, please resolve this!

 

Great review + Question

Overall rating: 
 
5.0
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
5.0
Reliability:
 
5.0
Reviewed by Brian
April 13, 2011
Report this review
 

Great review! I'm wondering how well it works when there are more than 1 set running? I have 3 rooms to bring into my network.

 

Fantastic Review - everything i wanted to know

Overall rating: 
 
5.0
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
5.0
Reliability:
 
5.0
Reviewed by MojoMohambo
April 08, 2011
Report this review
 

this review is outstanding. legit scientific comparison of the key measurables is all i ever really want to see. no rhetoric and garbage.
Well done!

 

Informative review

Overall rating: 
 
5.0
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
5.0
Reliability:
 
5.0
Reviewed by Rob
February 21, 2011
Report this review
 

Tim, thanks so much for this review. I tested out a friend's set of 85Mbps Netgear powerline adapters and while they did well for 720p media, they choked quite often on 1080p media. I've been following the new 500Mbps devices closely but hadn't seen any useful or in-depth review of them until I came across yours. I read your previous review of the 500Mbps TrendNet adapters and was disappointed about performance. I surely hope it's just a firmware issue there. I have a TrendNet TEW-639GR and I have to say it's top notch, so I'm hoping it's not the hardware design. I looked at their site and the last firmware they have for the 500Mbps adapters is two months old. *sigh*

If/when TrendNet released new firmware, are you going to test their 500Mbps adapters again? From your review I'm leaning heavily towards the Netgear 500Mbps, they seem to have their act together.

Thanks again.