Router Charts

Click for Router Charts

Router Ranker

Click for Router Ranker

NAS Charts

Click for NAS Charts

NAS Ranker

Click for NAS Ranker

More Tools

Click for More Tools

LAN & WAN Features

Introduction

The recent introduction of our Hardware Router Charts has generally met with reader approval. However, not everyone was happy with the performance of at least one the top-rated routers. The short story is that the D-Link DGL-4300 seemed to severly limit upload throughput when used with the eMule P2P file sharing application.

The jury is still out as to whether the problem is in the router itself, or due to ISP bandwidth throttling. But the discussion raised a valid question about our current router test methodology. The current method uses a combination of Ixia's Qcheck and IxChariot applications, and tests upload (LAN-WAN) and download (WAN-LAN) throughput, response time and UDP streaming performance separately using two computers on a private LAN.

The P2P Contenders

The P2P Contenders

While this test accurately tests the best-case performance of a router, it has its weaknesses. The most basic weakness is that it doesn't reflect how a router responds to the simultaneous up and download traffic that routers see in real life. And the 500 kbps rate used in our UDP Streaming test doesn't reflect the performance requirements of IPTV and other video streaming applications that are becoming increasingly important consumer broadband applications.

But more to the point of this article is that our current methods don't test whether the products can handle the dozens of simultaneous up and download connections used by gaming and peer-to-peer file sharing applications. So I set out to both devise a test to gauge P2P performance and see how a collection of routers from the top of our chart would hold up under it.

More LAN & WAN

Featured Sponsors




Top Ranked Routers

Support Us!

If you like what we do and want to thank us, just buy something on Amazon. We'll get a small commission on anything you buy. Thanks!

Over In The Forums

Alright, I signed up here just so I could get some help with this. So first let me set the scene.I own two houses, they are right next door to one ano...
An aquintance in IT pointed me in this direction when I asked him some questions. I've done a lot of research so far, but have hit a bit of a wall as ...
I'm putting the help request here because I'm using an ASUS RT‑AC68U / AC-1900 with Merlin loaded.I'm getting "DNS Server Unavailable" on a few of my ...
​ Pockethernet does the job of better-known handheld cable testers at around half the price.Read on SmallNetBuilder
I am running merlin 380.65 on my Asus N66U. Selective routing with openvpn works perfectly when started manually, but fails when "start with WAN" is t...

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3