Adding User Ratings and Comments

Photo of author

Tim Higgins

Although our product reviews are very detailed, they provide only one person’s view. And since reviewers live with products only for a very brief time, reviews can’t speak to a product’s long term reliability. So I’m thinking of adding a product rating and comment system.

The idea is to allow anyone, i.e. you won’t have to register, to rate products we’ve reviewed for Features, Performance and Reliability. You’ll be able to do this right from the article and you won’t have to register.

You’ll also be able to post a single comment along with your rating. Multiple comments won’t be allowed, since we already have the SNB Forums for extended discussions. The ratings comment feature is mainly to allow raters to provide a bit more information about their product experiences.

I’ll initially allow comments for everyone. But if this becomes a spam magnet, I’ll switch to moderated comments and / or require registration for commenting.

My hope is that this will allow readers to tap into a wider base of experience when researching prospective purchases. But it will be useful only if a significant number of people contribute.

So the question really is, if we add this capability, will you use it to contribute your experience and wisdom? Please let me know by leaving a Forums comment via the link below. (You don’t have to register, but the comment will be moderated.) Thanks.

Related posts

11n Draft 2.0 gear not working yet, but does anyone really care?

I share Glenn Fleishman's disappointment with this week's announcement by the Wi-Fi Alliance that they have only begun their certification testing. But judging from what I've seen so far, getting draft 11n gear up to spec is going to be a long, difficult process.

I spent a few days last week testing a D-Link DIR-655 router and DWA-652 Cardbus card, which are based on Atheros XSPAN silicon. These are the first products to have firmware and drivers posted that allegedly implement 11n Draft 2.0 compliance. My primary focus was to see whether the legacy protection mechanisms added in 802.11n Draft 2.0 were working in actual product.

Going back to our roots

When Tim Higgins first started Tom's Networking Guide for TG Publishing (TGP) I was not sure what would happen. But I did know that Tim was a unique voice on the Web, and we would not fail by being associated with him. Today, he launches SmallNetBuilder, and TGP is forunate to be a part of his vision. Tom's Networking always implied that it was a networking mirror of Tom's Hardware; Small Net Builder is a more accurate reflection of what the site is truly all about.

Linksys branding to be replaced by Cisco. No surprise here

The Uberpulse headline "Cisco kills Linksys brand, plans agressive move into consumer markets" is sure an attention getter, but comes as no surprise.

First, Chambers actually said: "It will all come over time into a Cisco brand"—which hardly amounts to an announcement that the Linksys brand has been, or will soon be, retired. And for those of us who deal regularly with the company and its products, it's really a statement of the obvious.