Introducing SmallNetBuilder’s Router Ranker

Photo of author

Tim Higgins

Introduction

We have improved the Router Ranker. Read about the changes here.

Now that you’ve been settling in with the new consolidated charts, it’s time to introduce the next step in the upgrade of our product research and selection tools. Meet the SmallNetBuilder Router Ranker.

The Router Ranker provides simple bottom-line product rankings for wired and wireless routers based on selected benchmark values. For each benchmark value used, products are ranked from best to worst. These rankings are then combined, with weighting applied when appropriate, to come up with the rankings displayed.

Just like the Performance Charts that they are based on, Router Ranker rankings are relative. This means that they will change as new products are added. Rankings will also change when we change measurement methods or tweak the ranking calculation.

Router Ranker Tour

While we were developing our new tools, it became clear that we needed to change our wireless product classification method. So we have incorporated the wireless classification system described here into all of our product research tools including the Ranker.

Let’s walk through the Router Ranker screen shown below. Note that you can bring up a summary of these instructions any time by clicking the How To Use link right at the top of the page.

SNB Router Ranker

SNB Router Ranker

You first use the Class filter to select the router class that you are interested in. The Rank filter lets you select separate rankings for (wired) Routing Throughput, Wireless Throughput and Wireless Range. The default Total Router ranking takes a weighted average of the three rankings to come up with a total composite ranking.

The left-most column in the Ranker screen displays the product rank. Underneath the rank is the calculated average rank value. These values vary among rank methods due to the calculation method. Rankings are relative with lower values representing better performance. Products with tied rankings are indicated by (Tie).

The next column has a product image, with two links below we’ll come back to. The third column has the product name and model number with a link to our review. A short product summary is below that along with current lowest product pricing. If you want to dig further into pricing or buy the product, there are links to our shopping partners. Please patronize them and help support us!

Going back to the second column, clicking the Performance link under the product image shows a summary of all rankings, along with the actual benchmark performance values used to calculate them, as shown below.

Performance summary

Ranking performance summary

The Features link shows the same product feature summary shown in the Product Finder.

Feature summary

Feature summary

We’ll be following up with advisors for NAS, Wireless (non-routing) and Powerline products soon. In the meantime, be sure to let us know what you think about the Router Ranker in either the Forums or just by dropping us a line.

Go ahead and check out the Router Ranker now!

Related posts

Microsoft Goes for BroadBand Big Time

Microsoft's official entry into the consumer networking hardware business has been met with mixed reactions from industry watchers. Some say the line of wired and 802.11b wireless routers and network adapters is priced right, and has the advantage of Microsoft's Support organization behind it. Others say it's a ho-hum offering, with little to differentiate it from the slew of established products from Linksys, SMC, D-Link, NETGEAR, and others.

The Truth Behind HomePlug “Speed”

We finally get to the bottom of the confusing "speed" ratings of powerline products.

A Beginner’s Guide To WAN Acceleration

Our short guide will get you up to speed on how WAN acceleration works and what it can do for your network.