Like every other website on the planet, SmallNetBuilder uses cookies. Our cookies track login status, but we only allow admins to log in anyway, so those don't apply to you. Any other cookies you pick up during your visit come from advertisers, which we don't control.
If you continue to use the site, you agree to tolerate our use of cookies. Thank you!

Router Charts

Click for Router Charts

Router Ranker

Click for Router Ranker

NAS Charts

Click for NAS Charts

NAS Ranker

Click for NAS Ranker

More Tools

Click for More Tools

NAS Features

Tags:

Introduction

2/27/2009: Revisions from vendor feedback

Is that an Approved Drive in your NAS?

If you have or are thinking of buying a BYOD (Bring Your Own Drive) NAS, you might think that you can throw any ol' drive that can fit into it. But NAS vendors spend a lot of time and effort to come up with lists of qualified or approved drives for their products.

But these lists don't include every possible drive. So you are left with the question: Should I stick with my NAS vendor's list of approved drives?

The Questions

I queried three vendors who put their products' reputations on the line by producing only BYOD NASes: Synology; Thecus and QNAP. I also contacted NETGEAR, whose ReadyNAS line depends on a mix of factory and user installed drives.

I asked them all three questions:

  • Why do vendors need to qualify drives for NASes?
  • What does their drive qualification consist of?
  • What risk do users take from not using vendor qualified drives?

Why Qualify?

The main reasons given for the need to qualify drives were compatibility, reducing troubleshooting and support variables, reliability and eliminating known problem drives. Of these, compatibility and reliability are probably the chief concerns. The next section describing the qualification procedures will clarify these further.

NETGEAR and QNAP also pointed out the need to ensure a match between a drive's intended application and its use. NETGEAR noted that its ReadyNAS home (Duo, NV+ and Pro Pioneer Edition) and business versions carry three and five year warranties respectively. So they choose their factory-installed drives accordingly. This can result in noisier business systems that run hotter, but that's the price paid for performance.

A visit to the ReadyNAS Hard Disk Compatibility List page, however, doesn't break out the drives according to product line. NETGEAR said the list is applicable to both product lines, but typically is used by people buying the empty chassis "home" products. They plan to establish separate home and business approved drive lists as they broaden their "business" product line and qualify new drives and drive vendors also continue to separate their product lines.

QNAP said they take drive vendor application recommendations into account for their approved drive lists. They didn't get into specifics, citing confidentiality issues. But they said that drive vendors' application recommendations do affect QNAP's drive choices.

Thecus cited four main reasons for qualification: drive firmware bugs; power consumption; thermal issues and SATA spec compliance. They mentioned two notable cases of problems with Western Digital and Seagate drives that had to be addressed via drive firmware upgrades. For power, startup power is a bigger concern than steady-state draw, since the power spike produced during drive spin-up can cause drives to not come up in time to be mounted and result in RAID failure.

The SATA spec compliance issue touches on issues caused by host-controller work-arounds for non-compliant drives. According to Thecus, while all SATA drives claim SATA I or II compatibility, "almost all" SATA host controller device drivers implement workarounds for some drives and don't work at all with other "black list" drives.

If one of the black list drives is used, it may fail to work or be detected by some SATA host controllers. And even if a drive is in a controller's " workaround table", it may not be able to operate at full speed with that controller. So to avoid possible data loss or performance degradation, these drives aren't included in approved drive lists.

More NAS

Wi-Fi System Tools
Check out our Wi-Fi System Charts, Ranker and Finder!

Featured Sponsors



Support Us!

If you like what we do and want to thank us, just buy something on Amazon. We'll get a small commission on anything you buy. Thanks!

Over In The Forums

Hi could you please consider reviewing the latest OpenWrt 18.06.1. You could flash it to the WRT 3200acm as this is one of it's features, to be able t...
Hyia all,I've installed my brand new Asus RT-AC86U with Merlin 384.6 replacing my Netgear D6400/AC1600.I'm facing a strange issue : I can't connect to...
I only know the basics so looking for some assistance. I have a heavy duty ASUS GT5300 that is our main router. It’s handling about 50 smart devices r...
View attachment 14152 ​ The dual-bay QNAP TS-215B NAS, designed for home and small office use, is powered by Intel’s 14nm Celeron J3355 dual-core 2.0...
CaptainSTX said:↑ I run all my IoT devices on the router connected directly to the Internet. The devices that use WiFi connect using guest networks ...

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3