Router Charts

Click for Router Charts

Router Ranker

Click for Router Ranker

NAS Charts

Click for NAS Charts

NAS Ranker

Click for NAS Ranker

More Tools

Click for More Tools

Wireless Features

Tags:

WPS is a wireless security setup protocol that the Alliance brokered as a way to get Buffalo, Intel, Atheros, Broadcom and Microsoft to stop working at cross-purposes. WPS combines elements of Broadcom's Secure Easy Setup, Buffalo's AOSS (AirStation One-Touch Secure System), Atheros' JumpStart, Intel’s Smart Wireless Technology and Microsoft's WCN (Windows Connect Now) into a single method for getting a wireless network securely set up quickly and easily.

As with similar brokered initiatives such as WPA, WPS has taken way too long to get into actual products. But now that it is, I don't think it really works.

I just, once again, tried a "matched set" of Wi-Fi Certified for Draft 2.0 802.11n router and card that supported WPS in both the router and client driver / utility. I started with the router and client in their "out-of-the-box" settings, which included no wireless security, but WPS enabled in the router. I got them associated and then pressed the WPS button on the router and in the client utility.

After about 10 seconds, the client and router reported successful completion of the WPS session. But imagine my surprise when I found that the connection was still unsecured! I ran the test multiple times, sometimes starting the WPS session on the client first, other times the router first. But the result was always an unsecured connection.

This isn't the first product I've found where a WPS session didn't automatically create a key and use it to set up a WPA2 secured (or the strongest security that both client and AP would support) connection. I had a similar experience with the Edimax BR-6504N, i.e. client and router supported WPS, session would complete, but security would not be set from an unsecured state.

I also couldn't get WPS to work on a D-Link DGL-4500. And while Trendnet's TEW-633GR supported WPS, the client utility for its "matching" TEW-621PC card didn't. All of these products have Wi-Fi 802.11n Draft 2.0 Certification and all, except the Trendnet pair, carry WPS PIN and PBC Certifications.

But my main question is, am I incorrect in my understanding that WPS is supposed to take a router and client card from an unsecured to a secured connection without having to choose a security mode in the router and enter a key? The Alliance's white paper states:

"With Wi-Fi Protected Setup, the user simply activates the AP and the client device, then either enters the PIN provided by the manufacturer of the AP (PIN configuration) or pushes buttons on the AP and client device(s) (PBC configuration) to initiate the secure set-up. The user is no longer involved in setting a passphrase; the security codes are activated and communicated automatically."

So far, I've yet to see this happen...and in products that have passed Wi-Fi certification that includes WPS.

So, somebody out there help me, please. What am I missing?

More Wireless

TRENDnet logo

How Powerline Can Solve Your Wi-Fi Woes - There's a better way to get WiFi Everywhere™.

Wi-Fi System Tools
Check out the new Wi-Fi System Charts, Ranker and Finder!

Featured Sponsors


Win This!

Insteon Giveaway

You could win a kit of Insteon Home Automation products!

Learn How!

Support Us!

If you like what we do and want to thank us, just buy something on Amazon. We'll get a small commission on anything you buy. Thanks!

Over In The Forums

Hi,I recently got a Netgear CM1000 modem on my gigabit Xfinity connection. When I hook my laptop up to the modem directly I am getting close to a giga...
I bought a AC3100 for use as my router. Worked great for a few days, tonight it seems to be throttling speeds to less than 1 Mbps. I have a 300+ Mbps ...
I know is choosable in the AC88 but in the website says the RT-AC5300 haven't the Media Bridge mode and my question is, is this mode enable in Asuswrt...
I searched but didn't see a thread dedicated to this. Anyone have experience with this? Looking mostly for a router where the company cares about the ...
I'm using an android app to send WOL packets to server that works on internal LAN, but not through OpenVPN. Can connect to server via VPN and ping it....

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Get Backblaze Now!