Wi-Fi Alliance 802.11n Certification Change Complicates Consumer Choices

Photo of author

Tim Higgins

The Alliance said it is making "only small optional additions" to

its Draft 2.0 802.11n Certification test suite to create the program for the released standard. It plans to start testing in "late September", to coincide with 11n’s assumed ratification.

The confusing, and potentially troublesome, part of the Alliance’s plan, however, is that products approved under the Draft 2.0 802.11n Certification process will be allowed to "use the approved 802.11n logo without retesting". The Alliance said it is allowing this "because all Wi-Fi CERTIFIED draft 2.0 products meet the core requirements of – and interoperate with – the updated program".

But the final 11n Certification suite will also test for compliance with four "optional" features included in the released standard (packet aggregation, coexistence, three spatial streams and space-time block coding). So once the new test plan kicks in, products with different capabilities will all carry the same Certification mark. The means that consumers will need to dig into product specifications to look for evidence of the optional features, assuming that manufacturers provide the necessary details.

The optional features all affect products’ maximum throughput, which is a key selection criteria for most consumers. In particular, the three spatial stream "option", really creates a new class of products, those capable of 450 Mbps maximum link rates. The Alliance’s announcement also makes no mention of single-stream (150 Mbps maximum link rate) products, some of which are not certifiable under current Alliance policy.

In the end, today’s announcement is a good thing for Wi-Fi product manufacturers, who will be able to simply remove the "draft" from their Certification marks come later this year. But it once again places an undue burden on consumers to navigate through increasingly complex product specifications to try to figure out why their "high throughput" wireless products, aren’t.

Related posts

We Now Test Wireless Extenders, Adapters and Bridges

We'd like to announce the launch of our full suite of product research tools for Wireless Extenders, Adapters and Bridges.

IEEE 802 Wireless Meeting Summary – July 2007

• 802.11-2007 Edition of the standard incorporating 802.11a, b, c, d, e, g, h, i and j was published in June of 2007. The following 9 amendments to this edition are now in progress: 802.11k, n, p, r, s, u, v, w and y.

• 802.11k – Radio Resource Measurement – has been forwarded to sponsor ballot; final approval expected December 2007

• 802.11n – High Throughput – 3076 comments received on draft 2 with 1594 technical comments; 1200 technical comments remain to be resolved; expect draft 3.0 to be approved in the September 2007 interim meeting; final approval expected at the end of 2008

Community Wireless Is Alive And Well

If you've been looking for information about building a neighborhood wireless mesh network, we've found a good resource.