|At a Glance|
|Product||NETGEAR ProSafe Plus 5 Port Gigabit Ethernet Switch (GS105E)|
|Summary||Semi-smart Gigabit switch that you administrate via a Windows application instead of a web browser.|
•QoS including bandwidth control
|Cons||• Tied to Windows for administration
• No port disables or link speed / mode control
Some of the comments in the SNB forums haven't been kind to NETGEAR for their new "ProSafe Plus" switch lineup of one Gigabit and two 10/100 switches. Folks seem to question the wisdom of the 16 and 24 port models being 10/100 only and all three requiring a Windows machine running an application for administration.
The answer, of course, is to bring the wonderfulness of managed switching to a wider audience in these times where wallets are clamped tightly shut. That cost savings is allegedly achieved by a design that uses a Broadcom BCM53114KFBG switch and Taifatech TF-480-ACL controller as shown in the board photo in Figure 1. (NOTE: The ceramic heatsink on the Broadcom switch was removed for this photo.)
Figure 1: GS105E inside
The slideshow provides a good walkthrough of the 105E's features, which will cover the needs of most people looking to add simple managed switch features to their LAN.
Figure 2: Admin Status screen
For around $60 ($20 more than the dumb ol' GS105), you get five auto MDI/X Gigabit ports, port and 802.1Q VLANS, mirroring, priority-based QoS, port statistics and in and outbound rate limiting. The only curious omissions are the ability to disable ports and set link rates and full / half duplex.
The features you do get, however, will let you segment your LAN for enhanced security (VLAN), easily do packet capture (mirroring) and control bandwidth hogs (rate control).
If you want more managed features, like port enable / disables, Link aggregation, SNMP management, Spanning Tree, multicast and 802.1x port authentication, then you'll need to spend another $20 or so to step up to NETGEAR's GS108T, which also buys three more Gigabit ports.
Although NETGEAR doesn't specify that the 105E supports jumbo frames, testing showed that it does. Figure 3 shows a slight throughput boost between normal sized frames and 4K jumbo. I didn't have to configure anything in the switch; jumbo frames are enabled by default. My guess is that frames up to 9K will work.
Figure 3: Normal and 4K jumbo frame throughput comparison
I also like to see how smooth rate limiting features are, since older products that I've seen handle this pretty crudely. Figure 4 shows that there's a difference between using Ingress (packets flowing into the port) and Egress (packets flowing out of the port) limiting.
Figure 4: Ingress vs. Egress rate limiting performance comparison
For this test, I set up an IxChariot throughput test with the file size changed to 1,000,000 Bytes from the 100,000 default. I started each test with the Rate limit set to 128 Mbps, then changed it to 256 Mbps and 512 Mbps. Of course, I had to change the direction of the IxChariot stream between the Ingress and Egress tests.
You can see that using Egress rate limiting yielded throughput much closer to the programmed value than using Ingress. So this would mean that the 105E can control a device's receive speed more accurately than its transmit.
In all, the GS105E can be a handy addition to your small network for real work, or as a learning tool for configuring managed switch features. But for only $20 more, the GS108T may be a better buy and, with its web-based management, free you to use whatever OS you want to manage it.
Related Items:Slideshow: NETGEAR GS105E 5 Port ProSafe Plus Switch
NETGEAR Introduces "Plus" Series, Semi-Smart Switches
NETGEAR Shipping Affordable 10G Switch
Smart Switch How to - Part 3: Bandwidth Control
NETGEAR GS110TP ProSafe 8-port Gigabit PoE Smart Switch with 2 Gigabit
Average user rating from: 1 user(s)
NOTE! Please post product reviews from actual experience only.
Questions, review comments and opinions about products not based on actual use will not be published.
|User Rating [Back to Top]||Overall:||4.3||Features :||4.0||Performance :||4.0||Reliability :||5.0|
Pretty Good -but
January 23, 2014
Report this review
I have 11 of these in my old network in offices that have been expanded. They have been excellent 5 port (and a few of the 8 port variety (GS108Gev2). because they are semi-managed, they make it much easier to find and correct problems on the network. They automatically fix loop and several other problems of networks build by, yes, students.
Two problems- they come with a class C subnet and must be reconfigured before installing, something most small switches don't need.
But the software proved, and updated (yes, i updated the bios on each as well) sees some of them, but not all of them (there are several varieties of this switch). Newer software would not allow the name of switch nor the ip of the switch to be changed. The last version (and I've tried 5 or 6) has finally allowed the switches to be configured. But hey are set up like home machines, using the 192.168.0 .... subnet.
So a little work to set up, Update bios, configure and name, then install. But they have performed perfectly ad I am planing on purchasing about 12 more for another poorly designed network.
I highly recommend these for problematic networks as you rewire and slowly fix the wiring problems.