Router Charts

Click for Router Charts

Router Ranker

Click for Router Ranker

NAS Charts

Click for NAS Charts

NAS Ranker

Click for NAS Ranker

More Tools

Click for More Tools

NAS Features

Introduction

In most of our reviews, we tend to focus on the performance of reading and writing large files. Our Windows Filecopy benchmark uses a ripped DVD folder with a few 1 GB VOB files and a mix of smaller files. And the NASPT File Copy tests read and write a single 1.15 GB windows backup file. NAS shoppers (and manufacturers) like to focus on these benchmarks because they produce the highest numbers.

Intel NASPT File Copy to NAS  Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

Intel NASPT File Copy to NAS Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

As an example, look at the NASPT File Copy To and From NAS charts shown above and below. These are for RAID 0 volumes and filtered for four-bay NASes. The NASes ranking at the top are based on dual-core Intel Atom CPUs, while those toward the bottom run on less-expensive (and powerful) Marvell SoCs.

Intel NASPT File Copy to NAS  Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

Intel NASPT File Copy to NAS Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

I was talking to someone the other day about high-end NASes and remarked that even multi-core processors can't do much to improve the performance of small file reads and writes on NASes. This is illustrated best by the NASPT Content Creation and Office Productivity benchmarks.

According to Intel's description, the Content Creation benchmark is a "scripted routine simulating a user creating a web advertisement from various content sources including video and 3D modeling software. 95% writes with mix of 1k, 4k & little reads. Wide range of writes up to 64kB, mostly sequential". Although there is almost a 2X difference between lowest and highest performance products in the chart below, 14 MB/s is still nothing to write home about.

Intel NASPT Content Creation Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

Intel NASPT Content Creation Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

The Office Productivity benchmark has more of a balance of reads and writes, i.e. "Common productivity applications: e-mail, spreadsheet, etc. running scripted routines. Balance of reads & writes, mostly 1k & 4k reads with a large number of smaller reads. Mostly 1kB writes, mostly sequential accesses". The chart of this benchmark, for the same group of NASes produces higher throughput, but less of a spread between lowest and highest performance.

Intel NASPT Content Creation Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

Intel NASPT Content Creation Benchmark - 4 drive NASes, RAID 0

Given the huge difference in performance, it's hard to believe these charts are showing the same group of NASes! But no amount of processing power can overcome the overhead involved with moving data over a network. Certain bits have to go into each packet to ensure that all the data you send safely arrives at the other end.

When the chunk of data you are moving is big, those overhead bits are a relatively small percentage of the network bandwidth used. But as file sizes get smaller, the overhead packets stay the same size and use up a much larger percentage of transmission time.

More NAS

Featured Sponsors




Top Ranked Routers


AC5300

AC2600

AC1900

Support Us!

If you like what we do and want to thank us, just buy something on Amazon. We'll get a small commission on anything you buy. Thanks!

Over In The Forums

Basically this just doesn't work as far as I can see. Drive works OK on USB2 but is just not even recognised on USB3. It works fine on USB3 on a PC.I ...
Hello now i try use huawei e3276s 4g modem in latest asus merlin firmware.I set manully frequency from auto to 1800mhz.With computer i can download to...
Hi all!Asus RT-AC68U, latest Merlin release.Has anyone an idea what does it mean:Code: Jan 22 13:57:52 syslog: usb_control_msg() in return: -22 in s...
I wasn't sure where to post so hope this is suitable place.I have an RT-AC87U with latest Merlin beta 380.65 beta1. I get native ipv6 from BT in the U...
Have L2tp setup, and workingThe IPSec I'm struggling with.So I have IPSec working:Proposal-sha1/aes256Windows peers work with peer as sha1/aes256iOS p...

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3