SmallNetBuilder

Follow SmallNetBuilder
Follow SmallNetBuilder on TwitterConnect On Facebook Google+Get the SmallNetBuilder RSS Feed
You are here: Wireless Wireless Features Inside Story: Linksys E-series and Cisco Valet

Inside Story: Linksys E-series and Cisco Valet

Print E-mail
Prev - Page 1 of 3 - Next >>

The Products

Updated 10/21/2010: Corrected WRT610NV2 and E3000 component info

Mommy or Geek? You decide!

Today's announcements mark an important point in Cisco's evolution of its approach to consumer networking product buyers. The company has established a new branding beachhead with the mommy-focused Valet line and is trying to make a clean break with its WRT past while imparting a subliminal "Expert" message with the Linksys E-line.

If the not-so-subtle message imparted by the image above isn't enough to tell you which line you should be looking at, then maybe the soft, feminine blue color (my wife says it's "French Blue") will provide a clue. At any rate, with plenty of similar Linksys-brand routers already on the shelves, how should you decide what to buy?

Figure 1 shows the new Valet products, which are single-band dual-stream N routers with 10/100 (M10) and Gigabit switches (M20). The Plus also has three internal antennas, the third used for receive only to goose gain a bit and try to eke out a bit more range.

Cisco Valet product line summary

Figure 1: Cisco Valet product line summary

The Valets are all about simplicity and just getting connected. You'll find precious little technical information in the product literature. Hell, the products are even called "HotSpots", not routers, the better to identify with folks who may now be getting their Internet fix at Starbucks, Panera or even Mickey D's, rather than brave setting up their own wireless network at home.

Figure 2 shows the E-series lineup, which includes single, selectable dual-band and simultaneous dual-band models, along with a Linux-based offering. These are clearly the choice for those don't-need-no-steenking-Easy-Setup-USB-key!

Linksys E-series product line summary

Figure 2: Linksys E-series product line summary

This line is intended to replace the current WRT series routers. Models include:

  • E1000 Wireless-N Router (MSRP: $79.99)
    Entry-level single band with 10/100 Ethernet ports
  • E2000 Advanced Wireless-N Router (MSRP: $119.99)
    Single-radio dual-band with Gigabit Ethernet ports
  • E2100L Advanced Wireless-N Router with Linux OS (MSRP: $119.99)
    Single band with 10/100 Ethernet ports, external upgradeable antennas, UPnP AV server and USB port for storage sharing aimed at fans of alternative router distros like DD-WRT, OpenWRT, etc.
  • E3000 High-Performance Wireless-N Router (Dual-Band) (MSRP: $179.99)
    Two-radio, dual-band with Gigabit Ethernet ports, UPnP AV server and USB port for storage sharing

Cisco told me that the rest of the WRT models, including G-only products, will be sold until inventory is exhausted. So it's likely you'll see both WRT and E-series for sale for awhile, depending on how fast wireless networking stuff moves at your local retailer.

But marketing spin aside, is there anything in these products that should make you run out to replace any Linksys N routers you already own?

If you want to cut to the chase, just take a gander at Table 1. It lists the Valet and E series products, their WRT-series equivalents and key devices used. Most of this information was obtained by peering at the often fuzzy photos in the FCC ID internal photo filings. As near as I can tell, it's accurate. But if I've made any mistakes, please let me know and I'll update the table.

Updated 10/21/2010: Corrected WRT610NV2 and E3000 CPU info
New Old Chipset
Valet (M10) WRT160N (V3) - Broadcom BCM4716 Intensi-fi XLR 802.11n 2.4 GHz Router System-on-Chip
- Switch: Broadcom BCM5325
Valet Plus (M20) WRT310N (V2) - Broadcom BCM4716 Intensi-fi XLR 802.11n (2.4/5 GHz) Router System-on-Chip
- Switch: Broadcom BCM53115
E1000 WRT160N (V3) - Broadcom BCM4716 Intensi-fi XLR 802.11n 2.4 GHz Router System-on-Chip
- Switch: Broadcom BCM5325
E2000 WRT320N - Broadcom BCM4717 Intensi-fi XLR 802.11n (2.4/5 GHz) Router System-on-Chip
- Switch: Broadcom BCM53115
E2100L WRT160NL - CPU: Atheros AR9130 400MHz Wireless Network Processor
- Switch: Realtek RTL8306SD
- BB/MAC: In AR9130
- Radio: Atheros AR9102: Single-band 2x2 MIMO 802.11n Radio
E3000 WRT610N (V2) - CPU: Broadcom BCM4718 @ 480 MHz
- Switch: Broadcom BCM53115
-5 GHz: In BCM4718
-2.4GHz: Broadcom BCM4322 Intensi-fi Single-Chip 802.11n Transceiver
Table 1: Valet, E-series and WRT comparison

The table originally had four colums, so that I could separately list the chips used in both the old and new products. But it turns out that I didn't need the fourth column, because the "old" and "new" products use the same chipsets, and it looks like, even the same boards.

Basically, the "new" E-series products are rebrandings of their WRT-equivalents. And aside from the girlie color of the Valet routers' enclosures, those products are WRT-series copies, too.

I'm glad to see that Cisco has not included any single-stream N routers in their new lineups, for reasons I've already explained. Of course, they could reappear as Cisco adds to the E-series line.

Broadcom is the big winner in this product line transition, since their devices populate five of the six new products. Cisco may flirt with other wireless chipset vendors from time to time. But they always seem to come back to Broadcom.

That's really it in a nutshell. No need to rush out and buy any of what was introduced today if you're already happy with what you have. And if you are in the market for a new N router, then you can buy either the new stuff or the models they are replacing. I'd keep an eye out for discounts on the WRT models, though, since retailers may be wanting to just clear them out and reduce their inventory.

If you'd like a photo tour of the routers' innards, just go to the next page.




Related Items:

Cisco Shuffles Its Wireless Deck
New To The Charts: Cisco Linksys E1000 Wireless-N Router
Inside Story: Linksys by Cisco WRT400N, WRT320N, WET610N
Cisco Valet M10 Wireless HotSpot Reviewed
New To The Charts: Belkin Play Max Wireless Router

Amazon Top-Selling Wireless Routers