How many versions of powerline networking do we need?

Photo of author

Tim Higgins

Panasonic’s adapter is based on its proprietary “HD-PLC” technology that advertises a phyisical layer data rate of 190 Mbps. In an unusually detailed disclosure, the press release contains a footnote stating “Actual data rates are 80 Mbps for UDP (measured using SmartBitsR network performance analyzer) and 55 Mbps for TCP data transmission (achieved on Linux-based FTP server)”.

Of course, no mention is made of HD-PLC’s ability to play nicely with either powerline adapters based on DS2’s 200 Mbps technology or HomePlug 1.0, 1.0 plus Turbo or HomePlug AV. But since there is no mention I think it’s safe to assume that HD-PLD, like DS2, at minimum won’t interoperate with the other technologies, and it probably won’t be able to be plugged into the same home’s wiring without causing serious problems.

The HomePlug alliance could have saved themselves and, more importantly, consumers a whole lot of hassle had they gotten HomePlug AV to market two years ago.

Related posts

Why Build Your Own NAS?

Bill Meade's Build a Cheap and Fast RAID 5 NAS How To has continued to be one of our most popular articles, even though now it's almost two years old. But with the price of ready-to-buy RAID5 1 TB NASes as low as $500, does it still make sense to roll your own?

Performance Charts Get Improved

Over the weekend, we've tweaked the NAS and Router Charts to increase your product comparison pleasure.

Linksys Range Plus is Draft 11n in Disguise

Today's announcement by Linksys of its "affordable" Range Plus product line (WRT100, WPC100) is an odd one. The product line is described as using "MIMO" technology to provide extended coverage at a price point around $100. But a look at the FCC Test report reveals the real technology used.