Like every other website on the planet, SmallNetBuilder uses cookies. Our cookies track login status, but we only allow admins to log in anyway, so those don't apply to you. Any other cookies you pick up during your visit come from advertisers, which we don't control.
If you continue to use the site, you agree to tolerate our use of cookies. Thank you!

Wi-Fi Router Charts

Click for Wi-Fi Router Charts

Mesh System Charts

Click for Wi-Fi Mesh System Charts


The last time I pitted powerline vs. wireless technology to see if either could handle the demands of HD video streaming was over two years ago. 802.11n wireless was still in "draft" form and powerline networking was still locked in a battle between incompatible HomePlug and UPA technologies.

As I write this in late summer 2010, 802.11n has been finalized for almost a year and HomePlug AV seems to have emerged as the leading technology for powerline networking.

IronMan2 Battle Scene

Can either 802.11n or HomePlug AV keep up with this action?

My recent roundup of HomePlug AV adapter kits found them more alike than different and almost all capable of delivering steady throughput in the mid-to-high 40 Mbps range. But while these results are significantly improved from past tests, HomePlug AV still doesn't have the rock-solid throughput that a wired Ethernet connection provides. So the only way to really know if either wireless or powerline can provide trouble-free HD streaming is to use both with actual HD streams.

How We Tested

I ran all of my experiments using a Synology DS109+, as the streaming data source. The NAS Charts show it (you need to show Archived products) at 59 MB/s read using the iozone benchmark and 73 MB/s read using the Windows File Copy benchmark. Multiple either number by 8 and you'll see that the DS109+ can have files read from it (as a media player would) at well over 400 Mbps.

For my player, I used my Acer Aspire 1810T, which has HDMI out and plays both 720p and 1080p content nicely. Since I used Quicktime clips, I used Quicktime 7.6.5 for playback.

In the HomePlug AV roundup, I noted that the Plaster Networks adapters were the worst for dropouts, so I used them as the powerline test pair. One adapter was plugged into the outlet outside the office, so that it was not behind the AFCI breaker that protects the room and the other adapter was moved to a living room outlet, then a dining room outlet. Those test locations correspond to wireless test Locations C and D, as described here.

The wireless testing was done with the NETGEAR WNDR3700 that I use as my home's wireless router and an Intel Wi-Fi Link 5300 mini PCIe card in the Acer Aspire 1810T notebook. The 2.4 GHz band was used in 20 MHz bandwidth (up to 130 Mbps) mode. The WNDR3700 is in a centrally-located lower level utility room and not the usual office test Location A. The Living Room and Dining Room locations correspond to test Locations C and D.

What does HD Need?

As noted in the Video Streaming Need To Know, and in the previous Smackdown, it's essential that you understand the bandwidth demands of the content that you'll be trying to stream. The best way to do this is to play the content from your networked source using an Ethernet connection while running a bandwidth metering program.

I've used both ReadError's NetMeter (free) and Hoo Technologies' Net Meter ($20), but prefer the latter because of its better plotting options and ability to clear the plot without killing and restarting the program.

You might frequently hear 20 Mbps or thereabouts described as the required bandwidth for HD streaming. This gets us in the proper ballpark, but doesn't paint a complete picture.

I used Apple's QuickTime Pro 7 to download 720p and 1080p movie trailers to use as test material. Figure 1 shows the properties of the 720p version of the Megamind trailer 3 used for testing. Note that the data rate is stated as 5.52 mbits/sec. So that should be a piece of cake for even an 802.11g wireless connection, right?

Megamind 720p trailer 3 properties

Figure 1: Megamind 720p trailer 3 properties

Now look at the actual bandwidth profile taken with Hoo Tech's NetMeter in Figure 2. Although the Avg Down throughput shown as 5.4 Mbps matches nicely with the file data rate properties, you can see a maximum of 19.1 Mbps, with frequent excursions above 10 Mbps. So the Quicktime properties Data Rate is obviously the average data rate, which doesn't help in determining what you need for flawless playback.

Megamind 720p trailer 3 bandwidth profile
Click to enlarge image

Figure 2: Megamind 720p trailer 3 bandwidth profile

Looking at the 1080p version of the same trailer, Figure 3 shows almost a 2x boost in average data rate to 9.4 Mbps.

Megamind 1080p trailer 3 properties

Figure 3: Megamind 1080p trailer 3 properties

Figure 4 shows the bandwidth profile, with an average down rate of 9.1 Mbps closely matching the 9.4 Mbps Quicktime average data rate. As we'd expect, the profile looks very similar in shape to the 720p profile. But the peak rate has almost doubled from 19.1 to 31.8 Mbps!

Megamind 1080p trailer 3 bandwidth profile
Click to enlarge image

Figure 4: Megamind 1080p trailer 3 bandwidth profile

So 1080p can still be doable with powerline networking or 802.11n wireless with a strong signal. But bandwidth headroom is significantly reduced.

Support Us!

If you like what we do and want to thank us, just buy something on Amazon. We'll get a small commission on anything you buy. Thanks!

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2