SmallNetBuilder

Follow SmallNetBuilder
Follow SmallNetBuilder on TwitterConnect On Facebook Google+Get the SmallNetBuilder RSS Feed
You are here: LAN & WAN LAN & WAN Basics Smart Switch How to - Part 3: Bandwidth Control

Smart Switch How to - Part 3: Bandwidth Control

Print E-mail
Prev - Page 1 of 2 - Next >>

Introduction

After our tours through port management and security, it's time to wrap up this series with a review of what a smart switch can do for bandwidth management. In the GS108T, these functions fall under the QoS tab.

Rate Control

I'll come back to the Global Configuration screen and instead skip right to where you can start ratcheting down bandwidth with minimal muss or fuss. Figure 1 shows the port-based Rate Control settings.

QoS Rate Control

Figure 1: QoS Rate Control

All you need to do is decide whether you want to control the rate of traffic coming into (Ingress Rate) or out of (Egress Rate) a port, select the desired rate from the dropdown and save the settings. The main limitation of the GS108T's rate control is that it may not be much help for limiting Internet traffic because there aren't a lot of "clicks" below 10 Mbps and only one below 1 Mbps. But if you need to limit traffic on your LAN, the settings are probably fine.

I ran a quick IxChariot test to see how smooth rate limiting was. Figure 2 starts with no limiting and then applied limits of 60, 200 and 400 Mbps. Implementations of bandwidth limiting that I have seen on previous generation smart switches and more notably in consumer routers, appeared to control bandwidth by completely turning traffic on and off and varying the ratio of "on" and "off" time. In contrast, the GS108T's rate limiting looks very smooth.

Rate limiting in action
Click to enlarge image

Figure 2: Rate limiting in action

Note that because a smart switch is a Layer 2 device, it can't rate limit specific services such as BitTorrent, FTP, etc. and it also can't rate limit by IP address. Rate limiting works only by physical port and all traffic through that port.

Priority Based QoS

With the simple stuff out of the way, let's move on to packet priority QoS features. Figure 3 shows the Global Configuration screen where you set the switch to handle packet priority via DSCP (Diffserv) or 802.1p. Both are protocols for communicating the priority of network packets, with the difference being that 802.1p is a Layer 2 protocol and DSCP is Layer 3.

QoS Global Configuration

Figure 3: QoS Global Configuration

The significance of the difference is that choosing 802.1p means that traffic will be prioritized on your LAN only. Once 802.1p packets hit a router, the 802.1p header will probably be dropped. This post, by a Microsoft QoS expert also mentions other reasons why 802.1p headers get lost. So, to me, 802.1p sounds like a not-so-good choice.

As a Layer 3 protocol, DSCP will survive going through routers (assuming they are DSCP-capable) and generally is considered more robust. DSCP also has the advantage of being visible to network sniffers like Wireshark, where 802.1p tags generally aren't. The reason why is mentioned in the Microsoft link above and in more detail here.

Actually, you probably won't be using either 802.1p or DSCP in a small LAN, since the sending and receiving devices actually have to set and act on the priorities communicated in the data. But if you do, the GS108T lets you map the eight 802.1p priorities (numbered 0 to 7) to four switch priority queues (Lowest, Low, Normal, Highest) if you select 802.1p based QoS.

If you select DSCP Based QoS, the DSCP Priority Mappings would be in effect. Figure 4 shows what those mapping look like. Aren't you glad that you have the simple Rate Limiting controls?

QoS Global Configuration

Figure 4: DSCP to Priority Mapping



Related Items:

NETGEAR Shipping Affordable 10G Switch
NETGEAR GS105E Briefly Reviewed
Netgear rolls out new wireless and low-cost gigabit switches and NAS l
NETGEAR GS110TP ProSafe 8-port Gigabit PoE Smart Switch with 2 Gigabit
Smart Switch How To - Part 1: What A Managed Switch Can Do For Your Sm