- Written by Tim Higgins
The ruling could have broad implications for the wireless industry as a whole. In May 2005, Intel, Dell, Microsoft, Hewlett-Packard and Netgear sued CSIRO in Federal District Court in San Francisco seeking a declaratory judgment that the '069 patent was invalid and not infringed. That action had been on hold while CSIRO appealed a trial court ruling rejecting its claim of sovereign immunity. The Federal Circuit affirmed that ruling in July, 2006. CSIRO has moved to transfer the cases to Judge Davis, arguing that the Texas court has already become familiar with the case and ruled on the key issues. A hearing on that motion is scheduled for November 17, 2006.
The 802.11a and g standards were adopted by the IEEE in 1999 and 2003. Virtually all laptop computers include 802.11g capability and Buffalo, Netgear and many others have sold 802.11a and g products to the consumer market. CSIRO estimates U.S. sales of 802.11g devises at more than 200 million units over the last three years and says the market is growing.
Intel is a major supplier of 802.11a and g chipsets providing essentially all of the chips incorporated into laptop computers. Dell and Hewlett-Packard are major sellers of laptops while Netgear supplies wireless access points and network cards for consumer use. Microsoft offers wireless capability for its X-Box video games. Perhaps, more significantly, Microsoft's new MP3 player - the "Zune" - will feature 802.11g wireless capability presumably to differentiate the Zune from Apple's extremely successful iPod.
According to CSIRO, the Texas court's ruling will apply to all 802.11a and g wireless devices. "The core technology embodied in the wireless standards was invented by CSIRO scientists based on their pioneering work in radioastronomy. The ruling that the Buffalo products infringe will apply across-the-board," said Daniel J. Furniss, a partner at Townsend and Townsend and Crew which represents CSIRO. The amount of patent damages in the Buffalo case, based on a "reasonable royalty," will likely be decided early next year, Furniss said.