Router Charts

Router Charts

Router Ranker

Router Ranker

Router Chooser

Router Chooser

NAS Charts

NAS Charts

NAS Ranker

NAS Ranker

More Tools

More Tools

Wireless Reviews

Airport Extreme Base Station - Simultaneous Dual Band
At a glance
ProductApple MC340LL/A Airport Extreme Base Station - Simultaneous Dual Band   [Website]
SummaryLatest version of Apple's 802.11n router with disappointing wireless performance.
Pros• Two radios for simultaneous dual-band operation
• High routing speed
Cons• No web administration
• Poor wireless range performance
• Can't use 40 MHz mode in 2.4 GHz
• No jumbo frame support
• Disk sharing choked on 1 GB file transfer

Typical Price: $90  Compare Prices  Check Amazon

Introduction

Update 11/13/2009: Added link to follow-up article

Well, it turns out that Apple never even responded to my review request this time. But my curiousity about whether Apple was performing a stealth seeding of three-stream routers in the the wild got the better of me. So I broke down and bought the new MC340LL/A model to see for myself and ended up disappointed on multiple counts.

As soon as I cracked the case, I knew that my three-stream guess was wrong. Figure 1 shows only four antennas, which makes two per radio. And since three-stream routers require three transmit and receive chains, the new Extreme won't be getting a three-stream upgrade sometime in the future.

Inside the new  Airport Extreme Simultaneous
Click to enlarge image

Figure 1: Inside the new Airport Extreme Simultaneous

I was also wrong in my guess that Apple just slipped a new radio module into the old dual-radio Extreme. The previous article showed that the previous Extreme used two Atheros single-chip N radios: an AR9220 dual-band, 2x2 for 5 GHz; and an AR9223 single-band, 2x2 for 2.4 GHz on a mini-PCI module.

Once I got the main board freed from the thermal tape that bonds it to the heat sink blocks, which, in turn, sit on a combination RF shield / heatsink that covers the top of the router, the view shown in Figure 4 was revealed.

New Airport Extreme Simultaneous board
Click to enlarge image

Figure 2: New Airport Extreme Simultaneous board

This is actually an entirely new board, with an all-Marvell design (processor, switch, radios) and more RAM. The new processor is a Marvell 88F6281 1.2 GHz "Kirkwood", which is a popular choice in current-generation NASes, instead of the 88F5181 in the previous model. The switch is now a Marvell 88E6350R 7 Port Gigabit. But Apple's case design still allows only one WAN and three LAN ports to be exposed, none of which support jumbo frames.

RAM has been increased from 64 to 128 MB, but flash stayed the same at 16 MB. Note the big ol' button-cell battery, I guess to keep info alive in RAM. A glance at the bottom of the board revealed a Pericom PI7C9X20303UL PCIe Packet Switch, which I assume helps connect the new radio module to the CPU.

I didn't take the shield off the radio module, so was only able to see the two Marvell 88W8366 devices visible in the photo. Since Marvell keeps details on its devices to itself and its customers, I don't know anything about these devices. But two antenna connections per radio says that it's a dual-stream-only design.

Amazon Top-Selling Wireless Routers

More Wireless

Featured Sponsors

Top Performing Routers

AC3200
AC2350
AC1900
AC1750
AC1200

Top Performing NASes

NoRAID
RAID1
RAID5

Over In The Forums

i need one portable wifi router which can take my 3g dongle.. my 3g is CDMA and i believe it is called EVDO Rev B.. which one would you recommend.....
Hi I know this has been asked many times before but im having problems with UK BT TV(Plusnet). On Asus stock firmware all i have to change Enable VPN ...
Hi all, I have a NAS on my home network, a QNAP 453. I want it to spind down to conserver power, however my webserver will prevent this as it is upda...
I have followed the wiki instructions for accessing my modem web UI on my AC66U's WAN port here: https://github.com/RMerl/asuswrt-merlin/wiki/Access-...
Hi Wondered if anyone can help me regarding a basic VPN set-up. I have a small office set-up and I want to have users tunnel into the office using O...

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3