SmallNetBuilder

Follow SmallNetBuilder
Follow SmallNetBuilder on TwitterConnect On Facebook Google+Get the SmallNetBuilder RSS Feed
You are here: Wireless Wireless Reviews Lots More Features, Lots Less Performance: NETGEAR WNR3500L with DD-WRT Reviewed

Lots More Features, Lots Less Performance: NETGEAR WNR3500L with DD-WRT Reviewed

Print E-mail
Prev - Page 1 of 3 - Next >>
Rangemax Wireless-N Gigabit Router with USB
At a glance
ProductNETGEAR WNR3500L Rangemax Wireless-N Gigabit Router with USB   [Website]
SummaryBroadcom-based 2T2R single band 802.11n router w/ gigabit WAN and LAN ports, USB drive file sharing and support for popular alternative firmware. DD-WRT brings lots more functions, but imposes a hit on routing performance and no significant wireless improvement.
Pros• Up to 4K simultaneous sessions (more via command line)
• VLAN and other "smart" switch features
• Wireless AP, bridge, client modes
Cons• 50% drop in routing performance w/ higher variation
• Wireless power boost doesn't improve range
• Hitting session limit locks up router

Typical Price: $44  Check NewEgg  Check Amazon

Introduction

The New To The Charts article summarized what the WNR3500L can do with NETGEAR's factory firmware. But most people will be buying the 3500L so that they can load alternative firmware. In fact, NETGEAR wants you to do that, since they pay an outfit named Capable Networks to run MyOpenRouter.com. That site hosts articles, how-tos and forums for hacking and tweaking the 3500L and NETGEAR's first "open source" router, the WGR614L.

Features

Some people load up alternative firmware on their routers because they think it improves performance. As I found in an earlier article (Can DD-WRT or Tomato Fix Bad Routing?) and as you'll see in this one, your mileage can definitely vary on this point.

But what you'll find for sure by flashing DD-WRT is lot more features. How many and which ones you get depends on the version of DD-WRT you use. Because some routers don't have enough flash and RAM to support the full smörgåsbord, DD-WRT comes in different flavors.

The superset of features for the current version is shown in the table below, lifted from the DD-WRT Wiki. The entire Wiki table includes a matrix of features vs. distros / builds.

V24_pre_sp2 K24 build features

Access Restrictions QoS
AnchorFree radvd
Asterisk Repeater/mBSSID
Bandwidth Monitoring RFlow
Chillispot Samba/CIFS client
Connection Warning Notifier Security Log
Dynamic DNS SIPatH/Milkfish
EoIP Support SMTP Redirect
ext2 Support SNMP
ext3 Support SPI Firewall/IPtables
Hotspot System Sputnik
HTTP Redirect SSHd
HTTPS Support for Web Management Syslogd
IPv6 (5) tcpdump
JFFS2 (6) Telnetd
kaid (Tx) power adjust
MMC/SD Support UPnP
NoCat USB
OpenVPN Wake On LAN
Pound Wifidog
PPTP/PPTP Client WPA/WPA2 Per/Ent
ProFTPd Wiviz

That's a very broad range of features, including modules to add VPN, wireless hotspot, VoIP and additional wireless capabilities. For the real hardcore tweaker, there is also command line access to the Linux OS at the heart of DD-WRT.

The handiest feature from a wireless standpoint is the ability to configure the router so that it acts as a wireless client or wireless bridge in addition to the WDS-based bridging / repeating you get in the factory firmware and from many other wireless routers.

Client mode uses the router's radio as a WAN interface to connect to another wireless network. In this mode, clients will be behind the router's firewall. Client bridge mode bypasses the routing function, connecting clients directly to the same subnet as the wireless network you're connecting to. Both modes support only wired clients, since the radio is being used to connect to the remote network.

If you want to connect to another wireless network and have wireless clients connect to the router, then you need to use Repeater Bridge mode, which requires WDS on both routers.

Also useful is the ability to adjust the transmit power beyond the range allowed by the stock firmware (up to 251 mW). But, as you'll see shortly, this doesn't necessarily provide improved range or change the throughput vs. range curve.

Figure 1 provides a peek at the DD-WRT interface, which is logically organized and responds quickly. To really get a feel for everything available, you should explore the online simultation of V24 beta. An overview of the web interface is found in the DD-WRT Wiki and includes a map of the menu tree.

DD-WRT Wireless Basic Settings

Figure 1: DD-WRT Wireless Basic Settings



Related Items:

New To The Charts: NETGEAR WNR3500L Rangemax Wireless-N Gigabit Router
NETGEAR Announces Open Source N Router
Slideshow: Netgear WNDR3300 RangeMax Dual-Band Wireless N Router
Can DD-WRT or Tomato Fix Bad Routing?
NETGEAR WNDAP350 ProSafe 802.11n Dual Band Wireless Access Point Retes

User reviews

Average user rating from: 5 user(s)

NOTE! Please post product reviews from actual experience only.
Questions, review comments and opinions about products not based on actual use will not be published.

User Rating    [Back to Top]
Overall: 
 
4.0 Features :
 
5.0 Performance :
 
3.2 Reliability :
 
3.8
 
Ratings (the higher the better)
Features*
 
Performance*
 
Reliability*
 
Comments*
    Please enter the security code.
 
 

Agree with your testing results

Overall rating: 
 
3.0
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
2.0
Reliability:
 
2.0
Reviewed by Li Tai Fang
January 29, 2013
Report this review
 

I bought this WNR3500L to be a repeater, replacing a Linksys astray because I needed the Gigabit ethernet.
Unfortunately, this is the first dd-wrt router I had that had such a poor wireless performance with dd-wrt. SNR is lower by about 10 comparing to a Linksys E1000v2 (also on dd-wrt) acting as a Repeater Bridge.

 

Tomato please!

Overall rating: 
 
2.7
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
1.0
Reliability:
 
2.0
Reviewed by heffeque
June 22, 2010
Report this review
 

It would be interesting to see how Tomato compares to DD-WRT. I switched from DD-WRT to Tomato some time ago with my Linksys WRT54GL and got better performance out of it, as well as a very improved QoS (it actually works! unlike the one in DD-WRT).

So... any plans on a Tomato review?

 

Finally!! Yes!

Overall rating: 
 
5.0
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
5.0
Reliability:
 
5.0
Reviewed by Ryedog
June 12, 2010
Report this review
 

Thank you Tim, I have been waiting for this for a while!! Would be nice to see Tomato also, but this is still great!

I wonder if it is a driver issue for the hardware that is creating the performance degrade?
The hardware specs seem to indicate it should get much better performance that this?

I purchased this router myself and loaded DD-WRT also. I only used it as a wireless app because my Verizon router for FIOS is way more powerful than this. The Actiontec MI42WR Rev E or higher is supposed to have Dual Core 64 bit processor in it? Would be nice to see a review of routing performance of this unit?

My experience with the WNR3500L was worse performance on wireless G than my WRT54GL both running DD-WRT latest version. So it did not make sense for me to keep this router although I expected much better performance of this unit. Sorry to say I returned it.

Thanks again for the great review!! Much appreciated!

 

Me too

Overall rating: 
 
4.7
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
4.0
Reliability:
 
5.0
Reviewed by uibo
June 06, 2010
Report this review
 

Thanks for interesting review!

I also would like to see a review of comparing the DD-WRT, Tomato, Tomato ND USB Mod and maybe even with some of the other ones (Oleg's Asus firmware, OpenWRT, HyperWRT, FreeWRT, XWRT) with the default firmware on a WRT54G, WHR-G54S or some other one with longer support.

 

Interesting

Overall rating: 
 
4.7
Features:
 
5.0
Performance:
 
4.0
Reliability:
 
5.0
Reviewed by Stan
June 06, 2010
Report this review
 

I have always been a dd-wrt lover, and the results of this test are interesting. In no way I am saying your review is biased.

Router freeze, when number of simultaneous connections is reached is a known issue with dd-wrt. The one thing that helped me get rid of it - decreasing tcp/udp timeout to small numbers, like 30 seconds.

I would also love to see a review of dd-wrt on time tested hardware, like linksys wrt 54G v1 - v4, and see if performance also drops on those.

regards

 
 

Amazon Top-Selling Wireless Routers